A landmark study has found that patient deaths surged 11% after private equity (PE) firms took over hospitals.
"There's going to be times in many of our lives when we or loved ones wind up in a hospital or nursing home. What might be less obvious is who's going to be making the decisions about our care. It won't say it on the sign out front, but these days, chances are increasing that the answer might be private equity. Over the past two decades, firms like the Carlisle Group, Cerberus, and Pinta have acquired hundreds of nursing homes and hospitals across the United States. The pitches generally infuse capital, cut in efficiency, and exit in five to seven years. And the deals work like this. A private equity firm puts some of its own money in and borrows the rest. Typically, it'll borrow more than 70 percent of the purchase price. The twist is that debt doesn't sit on the firm's books. It gets placed on the facility itself. So the hospital or nursing home now carries the debt and the interest on it, and they have to make the payments on it. A landmark study published in 2023 looked at 1,674 nursing homes acquired by private equity over a 12-year period. It found that after a facility was acquired, its interest payments increased by over 200 percent. In many cases, private equity firms sold the nursing home's building shortly after acquiring it, returning the proceeds to investors and then charging the facility rent on the building According to the same study, after these acquisitions, front-line aides at nursing homes, the people who turn over the patients, answer call lights, manage behavioral care, saw their hours cut by about three percent. Now, that might not seem like much on paper, but it turns out the results are devastating. The authors, economists including Gupta and Howell, found that private equity ownership can increase patient mortality by up to 11 percent. Over the study period, that translated to more than 20,000 lives lost, and the kind of care patients receive shifts too. One of the co-authors of that study noted that anti-psychotic prescriptions rose 50 percent in private equity-owned nursing homes, a jump that might reflect not treatment of psychiatric illness, but an effort to manage residents who weren't getting enough human care. Similar trend lines are visible with Authors Kanan, Bruch, and Song have found that when private equity acquires hospitals, emergency department salaries fall by an average of 18 percent. Hospital-acquired conditions rise 25 percent on average. Falls, infections, central line complications. To be clear, not every acquisition is all downside. Some facilities are distressed already. Some receive capital they couldn't have found elsewhere. But these deals produce harm reliably enough that researchers can now count it. The studies on this also serve as potential solutions, limiting how much debt a firm can place on a facility it just bought, tying Medicare payments to patient outcomes, minimum staffing levels, more transparency about ownership, maybe even restricting private equity transactions altogether. But so far, the industry has moved faster than the rules."
💬 Discussion
A landmark study has found that patient deaths surged 11% after private equity (PE) firms took over hospitals.